Armchair Genetics

Armchair Genetics


Thanks to those of you who reached out about our new guest post program. Today we have an excellent piece for those of you trying to figure all of this out on your own. Kiki Kish* will be doing a series of posts about her experiences and knowledge as a MTHFR patient, starting with this guide to genetic testing and what to do with the results.

I remember hearing about the Human Genome Project in the news around the time it was completed in 2003. Did I ever think how it might impact me and that I’d be able to get my whole genome mapped at my fingertips for my personal use to improve my health and that of my family? Of course not.

Well now you can get your whole genome mapped and find out what it means from the comfort of your favorite chair. The fact that lay people can do this and figure out what genetic anomalies we have, how they affect us and what to do about them is really a crazy testament to the modern times we live in, the power of computers and the utility of the internet. We’d prefer to consult with our doctor about it, but the reality is that most are no more up-to-date on it than we are. Practitioners or doctors who know something about genetic problems like MTHFR, the impact of compromised methylation, and how to treat it are hard to find. Thus, some of us choose to self-navigate this very new area of genetics for the common man.

I have been self navigating this kind of thing for two decades. As a self-navigator, nobody is going to spoon feed you; you have to do your homework to learn about it, and decide, perhaps through experiment, what the most effective treatment protocol for you will be.You’re into methylation now. It’s as individualized as you and all your thousands of genes are. While you may feel that grasping this type of information is beyond your capabilities, remember, knowledge is power. Take what you find and learn about it. Take it to your doctor and ask for her help, but learn about it first. They really should be looking at this anyway because in a few years, they will be dinosaurs if they don’t understand the information that is easily available to their patients. The best use of this information particularly in relation to methylation is in prevention of diseases as well as ameliorating conditions we already have. But it’s also possible to nip in the bud a disease process that has already started. One person used this information to find that a family member had a very high risk of lung cancer, and upon scanning, found three tumors for two different types of lung cancer. My uncle just passed away this year to lung cancer. He never smoked and ate an apple a day. I suspect he had an MTHFR defect but maybe he was just high risk for lung cancer. Mapping his genome may have shown that.

Back to self-navigating. How do you get your genome mapped? By using 23andMe or similar services. 23andMe provides ancestry-related genetic reports and uninterpreted raw genetic data. For our purposes, we want the uninterpreted raw genetic data. It’s a real bargain at $99. There are many other companies that provide interpretation of some small subset of your genetic data charging hundreds or thousands of dollars. To get your own genome mapped, go on the 23andMe website and order their kit. The kit is sent to your house; register it, provide a small saliva sample in a test tube, close it, shake it up, pop it back in their mailer, and in about two to three weeks, they’ll send you an email that your results are available. I don’t think the process could be any easier.

Then what?

There are a number of what I call genetic engines that you can run your DNA genome through to get useful reports that will help make sense of your genetic information and will also help you understand methylation better. Some of them will be able to access your data at 23andMe (with your permission of course) and with some, you will have to enter the data yourself. Here are four that I have found and a bit about them.

Genetic Genie

Genetic Genie is a non-profit site that will access your 23andMe data and produce a short but useful Methylation Profile report customized to the SNPs (single nucleotide polymorphisms or your genes) that they feel are most relevant. Like all the reports, the homozygous mutations are red (two defective genes), the heterozygous are yellow (one defective gene) and those genes that are normal are green. The explanations are good and while an insider told me that their engine is a few years old, it conveys what others say in a brief way that isn’t overwhelming in seven pages. They analyze 26 different genes, those of most concern with regard to methylation and related problems. The report is free with a suggested donation via PayPal of $10. Yet another bargain.

Know Your Genetics

This site is based on the extensive work of Dr. Amy Yasko. Although she didn’t intend to study autism, her work is really leading edge with regard to the treatment of it. I researched autism for my son back in 2000 and found her work extremely helpful. This site will take your manually input genetic information and provide a detailed report on your SNPs to recommend supplements that are categorized as general methylation support and also those that are specific for the individual SNPs that may be problematic. If you run the report from GeneticGenie you will have most of what you need readily available and the rest you can look up in your raw data on 23andMe (login to 23andMe, click on your name in the top right hand corner, and click “browse raw data”). Once you input your 20 SNP results, you can generate a Methylation Profile Analysis. This report is extremely informative, it’s about 56 pages long, and the list of supplement recommendations is extensive, with links to Dr. Amy’s site where the supplements are available. While the supplements listed in the report may seem overwhelming, they are broken down by basic methylation support and then recommendations for the individual problem SNPs so that you can consider the supplements based on the problems you feel are important.

The report contains a useful table that recommends the type of B12 to take based on two SNPs, COMT and VDR Taq. This is incredibly useful because B12 and the right type of B12 based on your personal genetics is as much of part of your personal methylation therapy protocol as taking MTHF folate. There are four (yes four) types of B12. More on that in future posts. But the coolest and most useful thing about Dr. Yasko’s sites is that any questions you have can be answered in their discussion group at www.ch3nutrigenomics.com. You can ask questions here and there are very knowledgeable people who will answer your questions. You may get seven slightly different answers, but if you are self-navigating, you will have to take the information and disseminate it yourself. Not a problem, you can always ask more questions. Many of the people on this forum put their SNPs of concern in their signatures. I’m sure they were all once newbie self-navigators, but are now further on the learning curve. One woman who answered my questions had 20,000 posts answering other questions. She seemed quite knowledgeable.

MTHFRSupport

This engine will also access your 23andMe results in order to generate a report. This report costs $20, another great deal! Nineteen pages of over 200 SNPs are nicely separated into several categories like thyroid, detox, methylation, clotting factors, celiac, mitochondrial, allergy and others. This report shows you what the risk allele is and which alleles you have. Another nice feature is that you can click on the SNP in the report and go straight to SNPedia (like the Wikipedia of genetic info) where you will find information on the gene as well as many studies on that particular gene related to the condition of concern. So if you observe that you have a number of anomalies affecting one category, you could go and read perhaps a dozen or more research studies on the problem and gain further understanding.

Promethease

Promethease provides very detailed information about your risk factors for many conditions as well as your interaction with about 100 common drugs. They report the good news and the bad news, your likely interaction with about 100 common drugs as well as numerous conditions and other things that have basically not been researched much yet. Warning: knowing your risk for everything under the sun based on current research can be unsettling, but it can also be quite interesting and useful and is only a modest $5 (make sure to download your Promethease data as it will only be on their servers for 45 days). There is a video on their homepage that explains how to download the report, unzip it and navigate it.

As an example of the information Promethease provides, one of my family members (male) has this BAD NEWS: is seven times less likely to respond to certain antidepressants, 6.2 times increased risk of developing prostate cancer, 4.5 times increased myopathy risk (for statin users), but has this GOOD NEWS: reduced risk of male pattern baldness, 10 times to 27 times lower risk of exfoliation glaucoma, greatly increased memory performance, 1.5 times less risk for physical impairment with age, and one copy of the longevity gene. Promethease ranks the conditions in order of import (a subjective measure), tells you how many references there are (studies that found that same thing), and the frequency with which it appears in the general population. It also tells you which conditions you have a normal risk for, which is comforting. A description and examples of the report results may be found here.

This kind of information can be overwhelming, but you have to consider again that knowledge is power. If I knew I had a significantly increased risk of something, I would do what I could to prevent that and also make sure I was monitored by a doctor for that condition. In 2007, my husband had an awful treatment for Hepatitis C (Interferon/Ribavirin). This treatment seemed to age him 15 years, and he lost 40lbs that he didn’t need to. It was probably hard on him partly because he is MTHFR heterozygous for both 1298 and 677 and did not tolerate the toxicity of it. Had we known that he had an impaired ability to handle toxins and was unlikely to have a response to this treatment, he would have never undergone it. Promethease actually addressed this treatment noting “ rs12979860 – less likely to respond to Hepatitis C treatment PEG-INF-alpha plus ribavirin”. Before that treatment, he was chopping wood in a manly fashion. After the treatment, he wasn’t chopping wood at all, but he’s progressing quite well on his methylation protocol, so who knows.

The only areas of medicine that I know that seem to be using this genetic information in a useful way is to tailor treatments like chemotherapy and medications such as those for mental conditions (finding who will and won’t respond to certain medications). I’m sure there are other areas, but it really needs to reach the mainstream, our primary care doctors, radiologists, dermatologists, rheumatologists – all of them. All doctors could be using it to help with diagnosis, medications and treatments. Educate yourself, use the information to benefit your family, and try and spread the word to get others on board. Whatever problem you have, improved methylation will help it.

Methylation is a critical metabolic process. Always check with your doctor or a qualified practitioner before starting any methylation related protocol.

Notes: Prior to November 2013, 23andMe (and similar firms) provided health reports along with your mapped DNA. They are now prevented by the Food and Drug Administration from doing so. Here is one report of why: http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/11/26/no-dna-testing-for-you-thanks-to-the-fda.html.

In 1992, my husband, 24 years my senior, was diagnosed with Hepatitis C. Hep C is a serious liver disease without a cure, so I explored alternative medicine. Now at 75, he is the poster child for transplants and health with Hep C, mostly because I became a self-navigating nutritionist, naturopath and now a budding nutrigenomist. In 2001, my son was diagnosed with Autism. Same thing, no cure, but I used supplements and nutrition; he’s in college making As and Bs. These two situations along with a parent with cancer caused me to do two decades of research on alternative therapies. I was often asked if I was in the medical field probably because I did my research to try and make sure that the doctors were doing a good job. I had problems for which I was prescribed medication, but the doctors, as usual, didn’t discuss what might be causing it. I determined I had a histamine intolerance problem, and in researching that for myself, I found that compromised methylation could be a cause. That led to MTHFR (I’m heterozygous for 677C). Once I did the research on it, as an engineer (M.S), I found the statistical prevalence of the defect and the risk of problems and diseases it causes or contributes to astounding. Everyone in my family as well as those in my extended family who have been tested have the defect and have many related conditions. And that’s how I arrived here.

If you have a comment that is related to your own health or have questions that require an answer, please leave these in the community discussion forums and not in the comments below. Thanks! =)

Share this:

Posted by Contributor & filed under Health Tips. This post has 8 comments.

8 thoughts on “Armchair Genetics”

For those impatient with wading through results for what they can actually DO, I recommend Nutrahacker. Lists gene function, consequences, what to take to compensate, and what to avoid. A limited report is available free, the paid report is comprehensive. None of these services is perfect; for BCM01 polymorphisms, Nutrahacker advises simply take Vitamin A – yet most supplements will be beta-carotene, which those with BCM01 cannot convert to Vitamin A – animal based sources are required.

Interpreting Your Results and Taking Action

Once you have your reports in hand, the real work begins. The traffic light system—red for homozygous, yellow for heterozygous, green for normal—is a simple way to see where your attention should go. But don't panic if you see a lot of red. Many people have multiple homozygous SNPs and are perfectly healthy. The key is to understand how these variations interact with your diet, environment, and lifestyle. Focus on the SNPs that are most researched, like MTHFR C677T and A1298C, COMT, and MTRR. These directly affect methylation and neurotransmitter balance. Remember, a genetic predisposition is not a destiny; it's a clue.

Take time to learn what each significant SNP might mean for you. For example, if you have a homozygous MTHFR C677T, your body's ability to convert folic acid into the active form, methylfolate, is reduced by up to 70%. That means you should avoid synthetic folic acid in fortified foods and supplements, and instead consume natural folate from leafy greens or take a methylfolate supplement. But start low and go slow. Overwhelming your system with methyl donors can cause unpleasant side effects like anxiety, irritability, or insomnia. Read Have MTHFR? How To Avoid Folic Acid In Food for practical tips on cleaning up your diet.

Also, consider other genes that affect methylation, such as COMT. If you have a slow COMT variant, you may be sensitive to methyl groups and need a different approach than someone with a fast COMT. This is why cookie-cutter protocols often fail. Your unique combination of SNPs determines whether you'll thrive on methylfolate or need to start with folinic acid or hydroxycobalamin. Experiment carefully, track your symptoms, and adjust accordingly.

Practical Steps After You Get Your Results

So, you've identified your key SNPs. What now? First, educate yourself. Read reputable sources, join online communities, and consider consulting a healthcare practitioner who understands methylation. Many conventional doctors are not yet up to speed, but you can bring them information and ask for their support in monitoring your progress. You might also seek out a functional medicine practitioner or a naturopath who specializes in MTHFR and methylation issues.

Next, start with the basics: diet, sleep, stress management, and exercise. These have a profound impact on methylation regardless of your genetics. Remove obstacles to methylation, such as synthetic folic acid, heavy metals, and excessive alcohol. Support your body's natural detoxification pathways with plenty of water, fiber, and antioxidant-rich foods. Then, consider targeted supplementation. Begin with a low dose of methylfolate (e.g., 200-400 mcg) and methylcobalamin (B12), and increase slowly while monitoring how you feel. Some people also benefit from trimethylglycine (TMG), riboflavin (B2), and other B vitamins. Keep a journal to track energy, mood, digestion, and any new symptoms.

Finally, don't forget the emotional component. Discovering you have genetic variations can be overwhelming, but it's actually empowering. You now have information that can help you make better choices for your health. Share your journey with others who understand. You are not alone.

Common Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them

One of the biggest mistakes people make is jumping into high doses of methylfolate or other methyl donors without understanding their COMT status or other genetic factors. This can lead to over-methylation, which feels like a panic attack, with symptoms like heart palpitations, anxiety, and headaches. If this happens, back off entirely and let your system settle. Niacin (vitamin B3) can help soak up excess methyl groups, but use it cautiously. Always start with the lowest possible dose and increase gradually.

Another pitfall is fixating on a single SNP and ignoring the bigger picture. Your health is the result of thousands of genes plus environment and lifestyle. Don't assume that just because you have a certain variant you will definitely develop a disease. Use the information as a guide, not a sentence. Also, be wary of supplements that promise to "fix" your genes. No supplement can change your DNA, but many can support the biochemical pathways that are affected.

Finally, avoid information overload. It's easy to spend hours analyzing your raw data and reading conflicting advice. Pick one or two reputable sources, follow a few knowledgeable practitioners, and take breaks when needed. Your health journey is a marathon, not a sprint.

Your Journey Is Just Beginning

You now have the tools to start exploring your genetic blueprint. Remember that this is an ongoing process of learning and experimentation. What works for someone else may not work for you, and that's okay. Trust your body and your instincts. Keep asking questions, keep reading, and keep sharing what you learn. The field of personalized genetics is still in its infancy, and we are all pioneers. By taking charge of your health, you are not only helping yourself but also paving the way for others.

If you haven't already, consider ordering your 23andMe kit and running your data through a few of the engines mentioned. The cost is minimal compared to the potential benefits. And when you're ready, check out our other articles on Homocysteine Levels and MTHFR and MTHFR and Pregnancy Loss for more in-depth guidance. Here's to your health!

© 2026 MTHFR Living